
When my boss told me that she wanted to fly me out East for a
business trip, I immediately started making plans to go to New York City and see as many Broadway plays as I could fit in. During the intervening six months, I updated my "Broadway Wish List" countless times. It was a relief when I finally got the dates of the business part and could start planning the fun part. Plays I'd desperately wanted to see --
Big Fish,
Waiting for Godot/No Man's Land -- closed, and Laura Osnes left
Cinderella.
Broadway in America announced that
Once is coming to Salt Lake City next year, so that freed up another slot for my trip. It was very difficult to choose, and for the most part I'm thrilled with the plays I saw! I even created the hashtag #sixplaysfourdays to help track the trip on Instagram!
Since she mentioned she had never been to NYC before, I invited my friend Theresa, and we invited her fun friend Kristen as well. I met Kristen once before the trip, and it was soon obvious that we would all get along famously -- we're all pretty laid back, and they shared my main goal of seeing as much theatre as possible. Whatever else we did/saw/ate would be frosting.
Note: I make no apologizes for being long-winded. A lot of people have asked about the trip, so I'm going to be thorough! Wooooot!
We flew overnight* and in spite of a tornado warning during our layover in North Carolina, we made it to NYC at 10:30 a.m, found a taxi, and headed to our hotel to drop off our luggage. President Obama was in town that morning to dedicate the new
9/11 Memorial; we passed his motorcade on its way to the airport.
 |
Me, Kristen, and Theresa in a taxi!
The driver was cliche and yelled at a lot of pedestrians,
but he knew where he was going and we didn't die! |
Kristen proved to be our subway guru. The concierge at the hotel gave us a map of the city and subways, and she never failed to get us where we needed to go. We bought an unlimited week-long "Metrocard" (good for all public transport) and high-tailed it to our 1 p.m. matinee of
Matilda. We made it with 15 minutes to spare. Good thing we didn't dawdle, and Kristen was such a savant!
 |
Lexington Avenue - 53rd Street -- our home station |
 |
The Sam S. Shubert Theatre |
I was more than a little honored to sit with Theresa during her first Broadway play (we bought our tickets before we invited Kristen, so she sat separately). This was the play I was the most excited about prior to the trip. I love the
Roald Dahl book and the musical soundtrack, and I've heard glowing reviews from nearly everyone I know who had seen it. The story is about a very smart little girl who loves to read and is neglected by her parents (the opening number is quite poignant, with bratty children being called "miracles" by their indulgent parents, at the same time Matilda is born to self-involved and neglectful parents). When she starts school, her teacher, Miss Honey, recognizes how remarkable Matilda is, but the Headmistress, Miss Trunchbull, takes an almost-immediate dislike.
The great reviews were NOT exaggerated. I can't say enough good things about this show. The set was gorgeous, the music was fun, the dancing was incredible, the characters and story-telling were mind-blowing... all of these things could be said about all of the plays I saw, I suppose. The emotional impact of
Matilda is what has stayed with me even till now. I'd forgotten just how hilariously awful Matilda's parents were, and it was such a breath of fresh air anytime we saw her interact with adults who valued her. The little girl who played Matilda was brilliantly funny and intense when needed, and everyone else played their parts to perfection. I wanted to hug Miss Honey and librarian Mrs. Phelps and Matilda's best friend Lavender, smack the parents, and was truly horrified by Miss Trunchbull. I was blown away in the second act at the realization of just how evil Miss Trunchbull really was, when a Matilda tells is followed by Miss Trunchbull's entrance in a red spotlight and blaring of horns. I knew how the story ends, but it was still nerve-wrecking to reach that point, and then I celebrated with the rest of the kids when they won the day! When it was over, I almost wanted to cancel all of my other show tickets and see this one five more times.

My only complaint was that I didn't anticipate that the matinee audience would be dominated by school groups. I don't think most of those kids go to the theatre often, and they had terrible manners. The worst was at the end of intermission. The second act starts simply with Mr. Wormwood (Matilda's dad and my favorite character) entering the stage, and launching into an anti-reading diatribe, followed by a truly brilliant song (during which his dim-witted son plays the ukulele...badly). I guess since there was no Entract, the kids or the teachers didn't realize the show was starting, so they talked through the entire thing: monologue AND song. I was so annoyed!! I'm pretty lucky that my parents exposed me to all kinds of performance art during my childhood. I should not be so judgmental about kids whose parents have other priorities.
I bought a magnet and a t-shirt from the gift shop before we headed outside. In true groupie fashion, we waited outside the stage door for autographs and photos. I'm disappointed I didn't see
Christopher Sieber (Miss Trunchbull) or Paige Brady (Matilda). Ah well. Doesn't mean they were any less remarkable!
 |
Lesli Margherita (second from left) played Mrs. Wormwood, Matilda's tarantella-dancing mother |
 |
Jennifer Bowles (second from left) played The Acrobat, and Matt Harrington played Mr. Wormwood |
We waited quite a while for the other stars, but finally hunger claimed us and we made our way to the
Shake Shack for dinner (we hadn't eaten since about 8 a.m.).
 |
Darn good burgers, fries, and shakes. My malt could have been maltier ;) |
We headed back to our hotel, the
Renaissance New York Hotel 57, to unpack and freshen up a bit. Our room was tiny, but had plenty of closet space and a fairly large bathroom. It was decorated pretty posh. We weren't breaking the bank, but it was a nice space to call home. From our window on the 16th floor we had a great view of the flags at Bloomingdale's!
 |
View from the room |
At about 6, we were thinking about grabbing a snack before heading to
Bullets Over Broadway, which I thought was at 8. I gave everyone their ticket... and then Kristen realized the start time was 7 p.m.! We booked it back to Times Square and once again arrived just in time for call. For the rest of the trip, Kristen and Theresa checked and double-checked the show times for every play. Sheesh, you make one mistake! Haha!
I counted 72 steps up to our balcony seats. That's a lot of stairs!
 |
"Gangsters should always tap." |
Bullets Over Broadway was a lot of fun. It's based on a
Woody Allen movie set in the 1920s where a playwright goes through a lot of trouble (from the mob, the actors, and his girlfriend) to get his play produced on Broadway. The main reason I wanted to see it was that it starred
Zach Braff. Sadly, he wasn't the best thing about the play, but that may be because his character wasn't particularly likeable. My favorite character ended up being the villain (I was not prepared for him to suddenly turn bad), and the second favorite was a classless moll who couldn't act to save her life -- that's the character description, not a commentary on the delightful actress. The tap dancing was wonderful, and the songs were old classics like
"Ain't I Good to You." I question the choice to end with
"Yes, We Have No Bananas" but the whole ending fell flat for me, so it could have been worse! It was typical Broadway fare: fun, upbeat, a lot of dancing and gorgeous chorus girls. Not a lot of substance. I might have liked it more if I hadn't seen
Matilda first. It was fine, but I kind of wished after that I'd seen
Beautiful instead. Oh well.
Since the play started and ended earlier than we expected and we still had a little energy, we spent some time walking around Times Square. We stopped at the Hershey's Store and a convenient gift shop so Theresa and Kristen could get their families' souvenirs out of the way.
 |
Macadamia nut kisses and Cadbury chocolate with almonds -- yummmmmmmm! |
 |
Something for everyone, as long as they heart New York. |
Lastly, since it was around the corner and a few blocks from our hotel, we stopped at
Sprinkles Cupcake ATM.
To no one's surprise, I chose chocolate cake with chocolate frosting ;)
We walked past Bloomingdale's on our way home, and admired the beautiful displays dedicated to the plays nominated for
Best Musical Play Tonys.
 |
Aladdin.
We decided they are showing costumes and contemporary fashions that echo the play's vibe (hence the red dress). |
We ate the cupcakes in bed, reviewed some options for the next day, and called it a night shortly after midnight.
*I had been really worried that I'd be so tired from the all-night flight that I'd sleep through Matilda, but that didn't seem to be a problem -- I was too excited! I might have shut my eyes for a minute during Bullets Over Broadway but I don't think I missed anything major (I hope).